Demand is a Construct…so let’s demand something REAL!

Economistic thinking is the default setting for understanding how the world works. Perhaps nothing illustrates this more than the theory of supply and demand. From hedge fund managers, to professors of economics and business and psychology and plant breeding, to policy makers and analysts, to students, to journalists, to grandma, to your average Joe(lene), when confronted with issues of resource distribution, supply and demand is the go-to explanation. The idea that markets simply respond to “what people want,” pricing those things based on “what is available,” might in fact be the most powerful idea shaping our world today.

But it’s an idea.

I’ll be quite forward: I don’t believe in supply and demand. I don’t think it’s a real thing, and I don’t think it’s even a good idea for organizing the allocation of resources. In relation to the hegemony of supply and demand thinking, one of the most difficult problems to arise is that we tend to mistake something that is a concept and a construct, for something that is natural, inevitable, and just “the way things are.” We reify it.

Pig Progress news from today provides a concrete example of this process: the article US: Funding to drive pork demand is a peek into the way that millions of dollars are expended to create consumer demand, and at the same time, to funnel capital to agribusiness. Demand, in other words, is a construct, with powerful forces behind every turn.

I imagine that one of the reasons we’re so keen on the idea of demand is that it makes us, as individuals, feel we have something to contribute – some power – in shaping the course of economies and societies and histories. But thinking of our engagement primarily in terms of what we do with our wallets is outrageously disempowering, and suggests more about the ways in which we’ve actually been disempowered in the course of the attempted marketization of everything.

What we buy is not who we are.

Purchases are not votes.

We are not empowered through consumption.

Understanding supply and demand as a theoretical construct has important implications, not least of which is the parallel that we should take the concept of demand and turn it into something real. I’ll start with a few ideas:

I demand a food system that isn’t controlled by corporate elites who use “food, agriculture, land” as investment categories; a food system that doesn’t make our air, water, and soil toxic; a food system that operates in a way that gives people dignity and nutrition and community; a food system that is inclusive and equal.

These demands have no price or market. We can’t buy them; we can only make them.

This entry was posted in Agribusiness, Policy and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Demand is a Construct…so let’s demand something REAL!

  1. What’s Going down i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively useful and it
    has helped me out loads. I’m hoping to contribute & aid other
    customers like its helped me. Great job.

  2. Adrianne says:

    Hybrid saws – Hybrid saws combine the good
    points pores and skin above three types of saws come up
    with them available at cheaper quotes. They are usually a mixture of cabinet and contractor

    The direct user. A different person may have been using
    it anyone and the opinion he or she can offer is important.
    They will give youu theeir comments pertaining to tthe product so that tthey can also
    agree or disagtee with company’s brags about the best portable table
    saw. They also can point thee actual good and bad stuff of them.
    They also can give their personal rating that wjll indicate iin the event
    the laptop bbed tray is indeed , worth costs.

    This is aan understandable mistake, but it will take more than onbly a desire to become a good player.
    Leads to learn to play on any small table surface and by
    using a very light aand tiny ball. It needs lighting fast
    reflexes, great agility and level of physical running. You will also are required
    to learn tthe various strokes andd spin choices.

    The purposes of them coming from rough cutting lumber to creating
    moldings. Many complex joinery techniques could
    be accomplished with tools, provided the user is informed about
    the pc.

    This saw gts terrific ratings . Gaathering Dewalt electric tabpe
    ssaw on the number of varied sources, I came uup with over a hundred different reviews ffor this model, by using
    a combined rating of five.7 out of 5 performers.

    The average ratingg wokuld be even highjer except tha some folks seem anticipate full-size
    performance and features in a lightweight, portable saw.

    I never said this list hadd been a budget list or bargain-priced.

    If you want thee table saw to beat all other best
    tabpe saw, this iss going as being a host once from a lifetime
    purchase, but you’ll need one table saw whwn purchasing this table saw.
    This is something you can hand in order to your children when builpt
    older, plus saw that could last virtually forever.

    Well, anyone and I bogh know, skinny-itty-bitty-striped-black-things wasn’t
    able to possibly ccatch fish under these conditions and Cleaning it once a to
    point that to bee able to her, while i netged her second trout.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s